Not signed in (Sign In)

SkillShare - A place to discuss Web Standards and Web Design topics

Categories

Vanilla 1.1.9 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

    • CommentAuthormista3
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2006
     permalink
    So, I'm getting bored with Wordpress. It's great, don't get me wrong, but I'm starting to wondering what else is out there for building mid-sized corporate sites?

    The last site I built is around 30 pages - when viewed in the Wordpress page manager it looks pretty unweildy, just a huge list of pages with no real hierarchy, making it hard for a client to make sense of.

    I also think the Wordpress backend is a bit clumsy looking, especially if you are using it with paying customers - I want something a bit slicker and more commerical looking. Enterprise-level almost I guess, but still very affordable. Yes there is the Tiger admin theme etc but it doesn't work in IE, so not much cop for Joe Public.

    I'm going to look into Drupal and Expression Engine I think, though I think Drupal might be overkill for a standard this is who we are/what we do type of website. Whatever the CMS it needs to have great support from other users via a forum, and tons of plugins. That much I know from Wordpress! Ability to natively handle document upload/insertion, inline images, easy linking to other pages etc a boon.

    Interested to hear your thoughts.
    • CommentAuthorMatt
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2006
     permalink
    Not to sound mean, but your crazy to think their backend looks clumsy. I think their database structure is perfect. One of the best structures I have seen.
    • CommentAuthormista3
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2006
     permalink
    I just mean the styling of the control panel, not the database structure (I wouldn't really look at that much cos mySQL does my head in!)

    Aesthetically and in terms of usability I think the control panel is a bit limited. My clients seeme to get confused by it... I think it's more the image/document management than anything.
    •  
      CommentAuthorAen
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2006
     permalink
    The Wordpress Admin Interface is stylable and there's a plugin which simplifies the Admin CP.
    • CommentAuthornimbupani
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2006
     permalink
    Wordpress is the simplest CMS out there. For anything that is 30 pages or less Wordpress is the best. Any CMS has a little learning curve.

    Alternatively you could use Drupal. Drupal is a very powerful system and has tonnes of support from commercial companies. The best part is the theme does not change from a web interface to the admin interface - admin users can edit posts on the same page as they view them. It also doesnt spout inline styles, so it is completely CSS and web standards friendly (though the default theme is using tables). It has a learning curve for the developer though.
    • CommentAuthorronin
    • CommentTimeOct 25th 2006
     permalink
    I recommend Textpattern, the most fluid and flexibile system I have worked with to date, much easier to work with than wordpress. Once you get your head around the use of textpattern forms and tags (which is easy) you can do pretty much anything.
  1.  permalink
    If it's good commercial paying client I wouldn’t even consider using open source like Word Press or Drupal.
    I probably will look at some commercial application.
    The problem with CMS it's hard to satisfy everybody with one system from a shelf and a lot time it takes individual approach for specific company needs.
    I agree I tried Word Press couple times and didn't like it a bit.


    Best, DS
  2.  permalink
    If it's good commercial paying client I wouldn’t even consider using open source like Word Press or Drupal.


    Just curious... why? If an open source application is the best thing for the job, why go with some enterprise solution that will cost more?

    We had a very well funded client at the company where I work (budget on the site was 6 figures). They wanted a blogging platform, so some genius suggested Community Server (the .NET blogging tool). In the end, the product they received took a great deal more time to configure and was inferior to what could have been achieved with WordPress.

    Find the best tool for the job, I say.
  3.  permalink
    It's true you can go wrong even with commercial application.
    Most of the open source applications have zero support or only community support which in most cases doesn't help much. Documentation is limited as well if there is any.
    Hmm. What else? Number of problems and bugs in application security issues.
    As far as blog and using WordPress I tried bunch of different blogs applications in a past but end up using MT Movable Type. Which is far better and advanced application then WordPress I wouldn’t even compare them at this point.

    Best, DS
    •  
      CommentAuthorkayloe
    • CommentTimeOct 25th 2006
     permalink
    I vote for Drupal over Wordpress and Textpattern
    MovableType is also a good option but is not released under the GPL.
    Each CMS is adequete straight out of the box, but to get it to do exactly what you need other addons are required.

    In the end it's a matter of personal preference, testing each CMS and working out the needs of your client.
    On that note, I would avoid using Mambo and Joomla because they are both difficult to use and to administer.
    • CommentAuthormista3
    • CommentTimeOct 26th 2006
     permalink
    Hmm points taken.

    Although it's not beautiful, the Wordpress backend can at least be simplified so that it doesn't bamboozle a client.

    I need to try out Joomla though to see for myself how it looks/works.
  4.  permalink
    I agreed with adjustafresh's comments...you'll save more money if you give OpenSource CMS a try.

    Right off the top of my head:
    Plone
    Joomla!
    Drupal

    Personally, I would take a look at Plone.

    As for Drupal, I've been following IBM's tools and techniques on creating websites using an OpenSource CMS.
  5.  permalink
    BTW, one could see a list of sites that used Plone in some way.
    •  
      CommentAuthornifkin
    • CommentTimeOct 26th 2006 edited
     permalink
    just to add to the fray: cms made simple has been doing pretty well for my latest project at work. (which i found out about from someone on here, sorry, forget who.)

    other things i haven't necessarilly tried but bookmarked here if anyone wants to look.
    • CommentAuthormista3
    • CommentTimeOct 27th 2006 edited
     permalink
    I tried CMS made simple but it fell down at the first hurdle. But I can't remember what that hurdle was right now, possibly the installation and nice urls config I think!
    • CommentAuthornimbupani
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2006
     permalink
    I agree Drupal has a learning curve compared to Wordpress. But Drupal manages to accomplish a lot more than what Wordpress is capable of.

    An example would be the MTV UK site - or even Project Opus.

    And also, the huge support system of Drupal makes it an unbeatable choice. Of course, there are companies that provide paid support and implementation like: Lullabot
    • CommentAuthormista3
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2006
     permalink
    MTV UK is done with Drupal- wow! That is impressive, I'm tempted to have a look at this more closely now...
Add your comments
    Username Password
  • Format comments as (Help)